Fairy and Snake - Steven Stahlberg Masthead - Tony Geer Astrobiology - Gerhard Hoeberth Emerald City Logo - Sue Mason
Archives Reviews Awards Web Log Subscribe Photos About Support Us

Current Issue
On line
A4 paper
US paper
A4 paper
US paper
Print Version

Art by Frank Wu
 

Hugo Recommendations

This is not official

What you see on this page is not in any way accredited by WSFS or the current Worldcon. This is a collection of suggestions from private individuals. The objective of this page is to give you ideas for nominees. If nothing else it should provide you with some very good reading. But of course the people who post suggestions here are hoping that you will nominate the following items for Hugos.

Confused about the process?

For a Hugo Award FAQ, click here. For details of the various award categories, click here. And for an explanation of the voting system, click here. When contributing to this list, most people stick to the official nomination rules and limit themselves to 5 entries in each category.

Don't take our word for it

Please don't nominate a work or person just because you have seen it mentioned here. Read some of the material (or watch it or whatever). Your vote is supposed to be your opinion, not those of other people.

Other recommendation sites

This is not the only site that recommends Hugo-worthy works. Here are some others you might try:

For a list of writers eligible for the John W. Campbell Award for Best New Writer, see the award's official web site.

Thanks to the Bay Area Science Fiction Association for providing a forum for discussion of Hugo nominations. Many of the people whose recommendations appear here are BASFA members.

You can see previous years' recommendations on the following pages:

How to nominate

In order to actually nominate (as opposed to just making recommendations here) you need to be a member of TorCon 3 or Noreascon 4. Nominations will officially open in January or thereabouts.

How to add your recommendation

If you want to add recommendations to this list, simply email the webmistress giving your name, the works you want added and the categories for which they are eligible. Every effort will be made to check that recommendations go into the correct category. Please note that just because something has already been added it doesn't mean that you can't recommend it too. Indeed, the more people recommend an item, the more impressive it is going to look.

The Emerald City recommendation list

Links are given to Emerald City reviews where available. For online short stories a link to the actual story is given. For online fanzines and their editors links are given to their web sites. For artists links are given to their personal web sites.

As a result of a decision of the Business Meeting at the 2003 Worldcon all works published outside of the USA in 2002 are eligible for the 2003 Hugo Awards. Recommendations that qualify under this one-off special rule are marked with a *.

Best Novel
Natural History Justina Robson Macmillan CMM, JS, NH
The Poison Master Liz Williams Bantam JC, CS
Maul Tricia Sullivan Orbit CMM, VJD
1610: A Sundial in a Grave Mary Gentle Gollancz CMM
Quicksilver Neal Stephenson Heineman CMM, MP
The War of the Flowers Tad Williams Orbit CMM
The Light Ages Ian R, MacLeod Earthlight JS, NH
Pattern Recognition William Gibson Putnam JS
In the Forests of Serre Patricia A. McKilip   JS
Down and Out in the Magic Kingdom Cory Doctorow Tor JS, MP
Coalescent Stephen Baxter Gollancz NH
Fuzzy Dice Paul di Filippo PS Publishing NH
The Etched City K.J. Bishop Prime AH
Ilium Dan Simmons Eos MP
Evolution Stephen Baxter Gollancz/Del Rey MP, KD
Singularity Sky Charles Stross Ace JP, VJD
Lost in a Good Book * Jasper Fforde Hodder & Stoughton DC, VJD
The Well of Lost Plots Jasper Fforde Hodder & Stoughton DC
Monstrous Regiment Terry Pratchett Harper DC
Idlewild Nick Sagan Putnam AGM
Redemption Ark * Al Reynolds Gollancz VJD
The Separation * Christ Priest Gollancz VJD

Best Novella
"Pictures from an Expedition" Alex Irvine F&SF (9/03) PW
"Off on a Starship" William Barton Asimov's (10/03) NH
Dear Abby Terry Bisson PS Publishing NH
"Curator" Charles Stross Asimov's (12/03) NH
"The Swastika Bomb" from Live Without A Net John Meaney Roc JP, VJD, CMM
"Welcome to Olympus, Mr. Hearst" Kage Baker Asimov's (10-11/03) MP, VJD
"Walk in Silence" Catherine Asaro Analog (4/03) MP, DG2
"The Fire and the Wind" G. David Nordley Analog (7-8/03) DG2, KAS
Riding the Rock Stephen Baxter PS Publishing VJD
"The Green Leopard Plague" Walter John Williams Asimov's (10-11/03) VJD
"The Ice" Steven Popkes Asimov's (1/03) VJD

Best Novelette
"The Empire of Ice Cream" Jeffrey Ford Sci-Fiction CMM, JP, VJD
"The Catgirl Manifesto: An Introduction" from Album Zutique #1 Richard Calder Ministry of Whimsy Press CMM
"The Writer" from The Book/The Writer Zoran Zivkovic Prime CMM, VJD
"Only Partly There" Lucius Shepard Asimov's (03/03) NH, ED
"The Chop Line" Stephen Baxter Asimov's (12/03) NH, KD, VJD
"From the Corner of My Eye" Alexander Glass Asimov's (8/03) NH
"A Study in Emerald" from Shadows over Baker Street Neil Gaiman Del Rey PW, DC, VJD, CMM
"The Swag From Doc Hawthorne's" Jack O'Connell F&SF (2/03) PW
"Tropical Nights At The Natatorium" Richard Paul Russo F&SF (9/03) PW
"The Immortality Plague " Steven Bratman Analog (5/03) MP
"Still Coming Ashore" Michael F. Flynn Analog (7-8/03) MP
"Paying It Forward" Michael A. Burnstein Analog (9/03) MP
"Hexagons" Robert Reed Asimov's (7/03) MP
"Legions in Time " Michael Swanwick Asimov's (4/03) VJD

Best Short Story
"Great Joy" from Changing Planes Ursula LeGuin Harcourt CMM, VJD
"The Waters Of Meribah" Tony Ballantyne Interzone (5-6/03) NH
"Sheltering" Tom Purdom Asimov's (8/03) NH
"June Sixteenth At Anna's" Kristine Kathryn Rusch Asimov's (4/03) NH, MP, DG2
"Gray Noise" Pepe Rojo (Tr. Andrea Bell) Cosmos Latinos MK
"Ancestor Money" Maureen McHugh Sci-Fiction MK
"O One" from Live Without a Net Chris Roberson Roc JP
"Hooyoo Love" Fred Chappell F&SF (10/11/03) PW
"The Only Known Jump Across Time" Eugene Mirabelli F&SF (9/03) PW
"Dragon's Gate" Pat Murphy F&SF (8/03) PW
"Demons" Matt McIrvin Nth Degree (12/03) MP
"Coyote at the End of History" Michael Swanwick Asimov's (10-11/03) MP
"Coming of Age" Mary Soon Lee Analog (4/03) MP
"Here's Looking at You Kid" Mike Resnick Asimov's (4/03) MP
"Four Short Novels" Joe Haldeman F&SF (10-11/03) VJD
"Smoke and Mirrors: Four Scenes from the Post-Utopian Future" from Live Without A Net Michael Swanwick Roc VJD
"Closing Time" from McSweeney's Mammoth Treasury of Thrilling Tales Neil Gaiman Vintage VJD
"Birth Days" Geoff Ryman Interzone (4/03) VJD

Best Related Book
Scores John Clute Beccon CMM, PW
The Thackery T. Lambshead Pocket Guide to Eccentric and Discredited Diseases Jeff Vandermeer and Mark Roberts (ed.) Nightshade CMM, JS, KAS, DC
The True Knowledge of Ken MacLeod Andrew Butler & Farah Mendlesohn (eds.) SF Foundation CMM, VJD
Backroom Boys: the Secret Rise of the British Boffin Francis Spufford Faber and Faber FM
Spectrum 10: The Best in Contemporary Fantastic Art Arnie and Cathy Fenner (eds.) Underwood Books JP, DC, LM
Dreamer of Dune Brian Herbert Tor MP
Giraffes?  Giraffes! Dr. & Mr. Dorris Haggis-on-Whey McSweeney's DC
Master Storyteller: An Illustrated Tour of the Fiction of L. Rom Hubbard William J. Widder Bridge Publications BT, KD
The Art of John Berkey J. Frank Paper Tiger JH
Flawless Imperfection S. Poyarkopv Natural History Museum of the Ukraine JH
The Cambridge Companion to Science Fiction Edward James & Farah Mendlesohn (eds.) Cambridge University Press VJD, CMM
Science Fiction Film Posters Tony Nourmand & Graham Marsh (eds.) Aurum Press VJD
A Short History of Nearly Everything Bill Bryson Broadway VJD
Sandman: Endless Nights Neil Gaiman DC VJD

Best Dramatic Presentation (Long Form)
Cowboy Bebop: The Movie* Shinichirô Watanabe Columbia Tri-Star CMM, KAS, DC
Bubba-Ho-Tep Don Coscarelli & Jason Savage Silver Sphere Corp. PW
28 Days Later Danny Boyle Fox Searchlight PW, VJD
The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King Peter Jackson New Line Cinema PW, CMM, KAS, SM, JP, DC, LM, DG2, VJD
Stage version of His Dark Materials Philip Pullman, adapted by Nicholas Wright National Theatre, London MJW
Angels in America Mike Nichols HBO LW, SS
American Splendor Shari Springer Berman & Robert Pulcini Fine Line Features MP
Matrix Reloaded Andy & Larry Wachowski Warner BT, KD
X-Men 2 Bryan Singer Fox BT, VJD
Finding Nemo Lee Unkrich & Andrew Stanton Disney KD, DC, DG2, SS
Wicked: The Musical Stephen Schwartz & Winnie Holzman Stephen Schwartz DC, DG2
Big Fish Tim Burton Colombia Tristar DC, DG2, SS
Elf Jon Favreau New Line Cinema DC
Pirates of the Caribbean Gore Verbinski Disney DC
Children of Dune Greg Yaitanes Lionsgate/Fox VJD
Peter Pan P.J. Hogan Universal VJD

Best Dramatic Presentation (Short Form)
"The Message" from the Firefly DVD Josh Whedon Twentieth Century Fox Home Video TW, NH, MM, VJD
Gollum's acceptance speech: 2003 MTV Awards Peter Jackson WETA Digital Workshop CMM, KAS, MP, DC, VJD
"Inside Out" from Angel Josh Whedon Twentieth Century Fox Home Video NH
"Home" from Angel Josh Whedon Twentieth Century Fox Home Video NH, DC
"Black Blizzard " from Carnivale Daniel Knauf HBO NH
"Shattered" from Smallville Patrick Bergin and Loretta Glade Warner Brothers NH
"Spanish Fry" from Futurama Ron Weiner and Peter Avanzino Fox LW
"The Devil's Hands are Idle Playthings" from Futurama Ken Keeler and Rich Moore Fox LW
"Twilight" from Enterprise
Mike Sussman and Robert Duncan McNeill
Paramount SM
"A Constellation of Doubt" from Farscape David Kemper and Andrew Prowse Sci-Fi Channel SM, DG, VJD
"Rosetta" from Smallville Al Gough and Miles Millar Warner Brothers MK, VJD
"The Bicycle Thief" from Dead Like Me Paul Lieberman Showtime MK
"Chosen" from Buffy Josh Whedon Fox VJD

Best Professional Editor
David Hartwell CMM, KAS, DC, DG2, VJD
Juliet Ulman CMM
Ellen Datlow CMM, MK, VJD
Stephen Pagel MK
Mary Anne Mohanraj CMM, VJD
Lou Anders JP
Gardner Dozois MP, VJD
Algis Budrys BT
Stanley Schmidt KD, DG2, KAS
David Pringle DC, VJD
Betsy Mitchell DC
Peter Crowther CMM

Best Professional Artist
David Cherry CMM, KAS, VJD
Kim Graham CMM, DG2
Simone Bianchi MK
Kinuko Y. Craft MK, DC

Luis Royo (note: adult content)

MK
Steve Stone CMM
Greg Manchess JP
Frank Kelly Freas DG2, DC, KAS, JH
Vincent Di Fate JH
Bob Eggleton DG2, DC, JH, VJD
Donato Giancola JH
Jim Burns VJD
Alan Lee VJD, CMM
John Howe VJD, CMM

Best Semiprozine
Locus Charles N. Brown CMM, KAS, JP, DC, VJD
Ansible Dave Langford CMM, KAS, DC, VJD
New York Review of SF David Hartwell, Kathryn Cramer, Kevin Maroney CMM, KAS, VJD
The Third Alternative Andy Cox CMM, KAS
Nth Degree Mike & Cate Pederson MP
Spectrum SF Paul Fraser VJD
Interzone David Pringle VJD

Best Fanzine
File 770 Mike Glyer CMM, KAS , DC , JH
Plokta Alison Scott & Steve Davies CMM, KAS, VJD
Bento David Levine & Kate Yule CMM, KAS, DC, JH
Zoo Nation Pete Young CMM, KAS
Emerald City Cheryl Morgan KAS, JP, DC, VJD
Fantastic Metropolis Luis Rodrigues JP
Revolution SF Shane Ivey JP
SFRevu Ernest Lilley CMM, MP, VJD
Banana Wings Claire Brialey & Mark Plummer JH
SF Commentary Bruce Gillespie JH, CMM
Erg Terry Jeeves JH
Fantasy Commentator Langley Searles JH
QuasiQuote Sandra Bond JH
Tortoise Sue Jones JH
Trap Door Robert Lichtman JH

Best Fan Writer
Bob Devney CMM, VJD
Mike Glyer CMM, DC, KAS, JH
Rick Kleffel CMM
Cheryl Morgan KAS, MP, DC, MK, VJD
John Flynn SD, BT, KD
Jeff Berkwits SD
Rick Klaw JP, MK
Dave Langford DC, VJD
Guy Lillian III MK
Sandra Bond JH
Claire Brialey JH
Milt Stevens JH

Best Fan Artist
Sue Mason CMM, KAS, JH, VJD
Frank Wu CMM, KAS, SD, MP, DC, VJD
Kurt Erichsen MK
Dan Steffan MK
Alan White MK, DC, JH
James Odbert KD
Brad Foster DC, JH
Melody Rondeau DC, KAS
Taral Wayne DC, KAS, JH
Alexis Gilliland JH
Terry Jeeves JH
Steve Jeffery JH
Marc Schirmeister JH
Stu Shiffman JH
Steve Stiles JH
Teddy Harvia VJD

John W. Campbell Award for Best New Writer
Karin Lowachee CMM, VJD
David Levine CMM, KAS, DC, VJD
Chris Moriarty CMM, VJD
Jay Caselberg CMM, VJD
MM Buckner MK
EE Knight MK
Nick Sagan AGM

Index of contributors

CMM = Cheryl Morgan; JC = Jay Caselberg; CS = Charles Stross; PW = Peter Wong; JS = Jonathan Strahan; MK = Mike Kingsley; KAS = Kevin Standlee; FM = Farah Mendlesohn; MJW = Mike Walsh; TW = Tom Whitmore; NH = Niall Harrison; AH = Andrew Hook; SD = Salvatore Dana; LW = Lew Wolkoff; SM = Sing Mac; DG = Dorothy Gail; JP = John Picacio; MP = Mike Pederson; BT = Bill Tanner; KD = Kirk Drury; DC = Dave Clark; DG2 = Dave Gallaher; LM = Leonard McVicker; SS = Spring; MM = Mike Miyazaki; ED = Ellen Datlow; JH = John Hertz; VJD = Vince Docherty; AGM = Anne Murphy

 

Emerald City Hugo Awards Section

Home | FAQ | Categories | This Year | Recommendations | Past Winners | History | Photos | Voting System

"Hugo Award" is a service mark of the World Science Fiction Society, an unincorporated literary society.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Site sponsors

Please support Emerald City by visiting our sponsors:

Your Ad Here

Web sites recommended by Emerald City Strange Horizons - an excellent webzine The online version of Locus magazine The Alien Online Diverse Books Tad Williams' Shadowmarch


Emerald City - copyright Cheryl Morgan - cheryl@emcit.com
Masthead Art copyright Steven Stahlberg (left) and Gerhard Hoeberth (right)
Additional artwork by Frank Wu & Sue Mason
Designed by Tony Geer
Copyright of individual articles remains with their authors
Editorial assistants: Anne K.G. Murphy & Kevin Standlee